-
The Situation This Checklist Covers
-
Step 1: Write Down the Actual Use Case, Not the Product Name
-
Step 2: Classify the Purchase by Supplier Type
-
Step 3: Get Written Quotes with Model Numbers, Sizes, and Weights
-
Step 4: Confirm Invoicing and Payment Terms Before You Buy Anything
-
Step 5: Put Delivery Instructions and a Receiving Contact in the PO
-
Step 6: Check What Arrived, Not Just That Something Arrived
-
Step 7: Close the Loop on Warranty, Returns, and Reorder Info
-
Things That Trip People Up
-
One Last Thing
The Situation This Checklist Covers
If you're the person who gets the email that says "Hey, can you order some stuff for the team thing next month?"—this is for you. I'm an office administrator at a company with about 280 employees across two sites. I don't have a procurement degree. What I do have is five years of order history and a few expensive lessons about what happens when you rush this stuff.
Below is the actual sequence I follow when sourcing things like a Motiv bowling ball for the company league, a Scythe board game for the break room, or a ProForm Carbon TLX treadmill for the wellness room. Seven steps. You can print it out and tape it to your monitor.
Step 1: Write Down the Actual Use Case, Not the Product Name
The request is usually a product name. "Get a Motiv Silver Sniper bowling ball." That's a starting point, not a spec. Before I open any vendor site, I ask three questions:
- Who is this actually for? (Employee wellness budget? Team event? Recruitment swag?)
- Does it need to match something we already have? (Ball weight, jersey sizes, existing equipment)
- Is this a one-time purchase or something we'll reorder?
The answers change the entire order. A bowling ball for a casual office event doesn't need to be the same spec as one for an employee competing in a league. A break room board game needs to be playable by people who've never seen it before—Scythe is a great game, but it's not a casual quick session. And if I'm buying a treadmill, I need to know whether the room has the right outlet and floor space.
I also had to look up what kettlebell swings actually are before I placed our first order for the wellness room. I kept seeing the term on request forms and didn't want to buy the wrong thing. Turns out it refers to a movement, not a specific piece of equipment—so the request was really for a kettlebell set, not a machine. Ten minutes of reading saved me from ordering something nobody wanted.
Checkpoint: You can describe the user and the setting in one sentence. If you can't, you're not ready to order.
I learned this the hard way. In 2022, I ordered a set of jerseys in what the vendor called "standard office sizes." I didn't ask what that actually meant. The vendor meant men's standard. About a third of our team is women. Half the order didn't fit. I ended up eating the return shipping because our purchase order didn't have a return clause. That was a $600 lesson in why "standard" is not a spec.
Step 2: Classify the Purchase by Supplier Type
Not everything should come from the same vendor. When I checked our last fiscal year, I found that roughly 65–70% of our equipment purchases were going through two "general" suppliers who charged a markup on almost everything. Not because they were bad—because they were convenient.
Here's the split I use now:
- Specialty equipment (bowling balls, tape, cleaners, bags) → dedicated suppliers. For us, motiv-bowling is our main ball and accessory source. They know the product line, and the pricing on bulk orders is reasonable.
- Fitness equipment (treadmill, kettlebells, mats) → a vendor that handles warranty service, not just delivery. A ProForm Carbon TLX treadmill is a solid mid-range choice, but it's heavy, and if something goes wrong with the console, I don't want to be the one boxing it up and shipping it back. I need the vendor to handle warranty claims.
- Break room / social (board games, small electronics) → whoever has the best price with a return policy. Scythe board game retail packaging is pretty standard, so this is a lower-risk category.
- Custom or branded items (jerseys, bags with logo) → a vendor who will send a proof before production. No exceptions.
I don't have hard data on how much consolidation actually saves across the industry—I've heard numbers anywhere from 8% to 20%, but I haven't tracked it closely enough to give you a reliable figure. Anecdotally, moving specialty items to a dedicated source (what we did with Motiv bowling gear) made our order accuracy much better. Fewer wrong-item deliveries.
Step 3: Get Written Quotes with Model Numbers, Sizes, and Weights
A verbal "yeah, we can get that" is not a quote. A product page screenshot is not a quote. A quote is a document that lists the exact SKU, quantity, unit price, and any shipping or handling fees.
For something like the Motiv Fatal Venom bowling ball, the SKU and ball weight matter. If I ask for "the Motiv Fatal Venom," the vendor might assume 15 pounds. The person who requested it might throw 14. That's not a mistake you can fix by email—someone has to physically exchange a drilled bowling ball.
For fitness equipment, the equivalent is voltage, footprint, and delivery coordination. A treadmill that doesn't fit through the wellness room door is a very expensive hall decoration. I now ask for the assembled dimensions in writing before any treadmill purchase. I got burned on this in 2023—not with a treadmill, but with a rowing machine that arrived bolted together. We had to remove a door frame.
Per FTC advertising guidelines, any seller making a performance claim should be able to back it up with evidence. So if a vendor tells you their treadmill "supports up to 400 pounds" or their bowling ball "guarantees 30% more hook," you can ask for the test data. I don't usually push that hard, but I do keep notes on what was promised in writing. It's saved me twice.
Checkpoint: The quote should have enough detail that someone else could receive the shipment and verify it without calling you.
Step 4: Confirm Invoicing and Payment Terms Before You Buy Anything
This is the step most people skip. I skipped it once and it cost me $2,400.
Our finance team has specific requirements: PO number on the invoice, itemized line items, tax-exempt status flagged correctly, and a PDF or portal submission. If a vendor can't meet those requirements, I can't buy from them—no matter how good the price is.
I found a great deal on some promotional items from a new vendor in 2021. They sent a handwritten receipt. I submitted it anyway. Finance rejected it. I had to cover the expense from the department budget because the money was already spent and the vendor had no invoice process. I didn't make that mistake again.
Before I place any order now, I ask three questions:
- Can you send a proper invoice with our PO number on it?
- What is your payment term—Net 30, due on receipt, or prepay?
- Who do I contact if the invoice is wrong?
If the vendor hesitates on question one, I move on. A vendor who can't produce a compliant invoice is a vendor who will cause me more work than they save. It's not about being picky—it's about closing the loop so finance doesn't have to chase paperwork.
Step 5: Put Delivery Instructions and a Receiving Contact in the PO
If you are ordering a bowling ball, a board game, and a treadmill from three different vendors, they will not all arrive on the same day. And none of them will call the right person if you don't tell them who to call.
I include delivery instructions on every PO now:
- Receiving hours (our dock is open 9–3, not 5 PM, which is when one freight company tried to deliver a treadmill)
- Contact name and phone number
- Where to leave the item if no one signs (locker room, front desk, etc.)
I also ask vendors to provide tracking information. This is not a control thing—it's because the number of packages that arrive without a label on the box, or go to the wrong building, is higher than you'd think.
If you're shipping things via USPS, the envelope and package standards matter. USPS defines a standard letter as 3.5" × 5" minimum to 6.125" × 11.5" maximum—anything larger is a large envelope or a package. This sounds obvious until you're mailing a check to a vendor and finance asks why the postage was wrong. I use the USPS Business Mail 101 page when I need to verify.
Step 6: Check What Arrived, Not Just That Something Arrived
The package is on your desk. That doesn't mean the order is correct.
My receiving checklist:
- Open the box. All the way.
- Match what's inside to the quote line items—quantity, size, SKU, color.
- Check for damage. Take photos before you throw away the packaging.
- Note any discrepancy within 24 hours. Most vendors have a short window for shipping claims.
This sounds basic, but yeah, I've missed it. In 2024, I signed for a delivery of bowling bags without opening the box. Three of the bags were the wrong color—close, but not what we ordered. By the time I found out, we were past the vendor's seven-day claim window. We ended up donating them to a youth league, which was nice, but not the plan.
I've processed maybe 400 orders. 380, give or take, I'd have to check the system. Out of those, I can remember about six that arrived with something wrong. Not a huge percentage, but six conversations I'd rather not repeat.
Checkpoint: Someone other than the person who placed the order should verify the delivery. It's too easy to see what you expect to see when you're the one who ordered it.
Step 7: Close the Loop on Warranty, Returns, and Reorder Info
The order is done. But before you file the paperwork, capture two things:
- Warranty terms. For the ProForm Carbon TLX, for example, the frame and motor warranty is longer than the parts warranty. I write the warranty period and contact number on the asset tag so we don't have to dig through emails two years from now.
- Reorder details. SKU, vendor contact, price at time of order, and the date. When someone asks for "the same bowling tape we got last time," you'll need this.
I keep a simple spreadsheet. No fancy procurement software. Vendor name, item, SKU, price, date, warranty end date, contact. That's it. But it's saved me at least three hours a month in "what did we order and when" conversations.
If I remember correctly, the first time I set this up was in 2022, though I might be misremembering the exact month. The point is that it took an afternoon and it's paid for itself many times over.
Things That Trip People Up
Assuming "standard" means what you think it means. It doesn't. Whether it's bowling ball weight, jersey sizing, or paper stock for printed materials, always get the spec in writing.
Letting the vendor pick the ship date. If you don't specify a delivery window, they'll pick what's convenient for them. Your event will be over by then.
Forgetting that not all vendors can handle your invoicing setup. A vendor who can't send a compliant invoice is a vendor who will cost you more time than you save. Verify before you buy.
Trusting a verbal quote over a written one. If it's not in writing, it didn't happen. A vendor's memory of the conversation will not match yours when you're disputing a charge.
Buying fitness equipment without checking the delivery path. A treadmill fits through a standard office door. A treadmill in its shipping crate does not. Verify the crate dimensions too.
One Last Thing
I can only speak to my situation—mid-size company, two locations, a finance team that enforces invoicing rules, and a wellness room that actually gets used. If you're at a smaller company with looser payment processes, some of this will feel overly cautious. That's fine. But if you're in a larger organization where finance audits expenses, skip any of the above and see what happens. I've already tested it for you. The answer is that it doesn't work.
The list isn't long because I like checklists. It's short because I've made the mistakes that make a longer checklist necessary.